At Weathertight Roofing, we’ve seen it all — roofs that failed early because the homeowner didn’t know what to ask, and others that lasted decades because they partnered with a transparent, skilled contractor. Replacing your roof is one of the most important investments you’ll make in your home. But how do you know you’re hiring the right roofing company? The truth is, a handshake and a quote aren’t enough — the questions you ask before signing a contract can save you thousands. Here’s our guide to help you ask the right things and spot the red flags before you sign.
Can You Show Me Proof of License and Insurance?
This is the first question you should ask. Any legitimate roofer should hold a valid contractor’s license and carry both liability and workers’ compensation insurance. Why it matters: If a roofer gets injured on your property and isn’t covered, you could be held responsible. Likewise, if the work damages your home, uninsured contractors can disappear overnight — leaving you with the bill. At Weathertight Roofing, we proudly show all documentation before work begins. Transparency isn’t optional — it’s our policy.
What Exactly Does the Roof Replacement Include?
Not all quotes are created equal. Some contractors throw out a low number that hides costs later. Make sure your estimate clearly lists: tear-off and disposal of old materials, underlayment, flashing, vents, decking work, cleanup, warranty, and post-inspection. When you partner with Weathertight Roofing for a roof replacement we break down every step, every material, and every warranty term before you sign — no hidden fees, no guesswork.
Who Will Actually Be Working on My Roof?
Surprisingly, many roofing companies subcontract without telling you. You might think you hired a local team, but an unverified crew shows up instead. Ask your roofer: Are they full-time employees or subcontractors? Who supervises the project? Who should you contact if issues arise? Every project is handled by our in-house team of trained professionals. We don’t outsource trust.
What Warranties Do You Offer on Labor and Materials?
A warranty tells you how confident a contractor is in their work. There are two types you need: Manufacturer’s warranty (covers roofing materials) and Workmanship warranty (covers installation). Some roofers only offer one or rely on manufacturer coverage alone — leaving gaps if a leak is due to poor installation. We offer both. Our roof replacement warranty includes product protection and craftsmanship coverage, so you’re protected from every angle.
How Long Will the Roof Replacement Take?
Time matters — especially if you’re living under the construction zone. Ask your roofer: What’s the expected start and finish date? How many workers will be on site? What happens if weather delays occur? A reputable company gives a realistic timeline and communicates updates promptly. We take pride in scheduled projects around your life, not the other way around, keeping your home secure from day one.
What Payment Schedule Do You Require?
If a roofer asks for full payment upfront — run. Standard industry practice is a small deposit to secure your spot, partial payment midway (materials), and final payment only after the project passes inspection. Weathertight Roofing never requires full prepayment. We believe trust should be earned, not demanded.
What Sets Your Roofing Company Apart?
Here’s where a roofer’s character shines. Are they proud of their work, or are they reading from a script? Our answer is simple: Weathertight Roofing has been protecting homes for over four decades with craftsmanship built on honesty, quality, and accountability. When we put our name on a project, we’re promising more than a roof — we’re guaranteeing reliability that lasts. Every roof replacement we complete is backed by rigorous inspection, premium materials, and a commitment to make your home truly weathertight.
Bonus: Red Flags to Watch Out For
Even if the contractor sounds good, beware of vague or missing paperwork, unmarked vehicles or crews without ID, pressure to sign “today only” offers, refusal to list materials or warranty details, or reviews that look copied or inconsistent. When in doubt — verify everything in writing. A legitimate roofing company will never rush your decision.
Final Thoughts
Before you sign any roofing contract, ask these questions. The right roofer will welcome your curiosity — because good contractors want educated homeowners. At Weathertight Roofing, we believe in building roofs that last and relationships that last longer. If you’re considering a roof replacement we invite you to talk to us first. We’ll walk you through every answer, show you our proof, and leave you feeling confident, not pressured. Because when it comes to your home’s roof, you deserve honesty as strong as the shingles above your head
